Tag Archive for ngcm2011

Cheddar-Bacon-Pepper jack Grilled Cheese

So many people are looking for my old grilled cheese posts from version 1 of this blog, I’ve decided to re-post a few.  This one is a cheddar bacon pepper jack grilled cheese made by my special lady friend back in April of 2011.


  • Two slices of bread
  • Unsalted butter
  • Two slices medium cheddar cheese
  • Two or three slices pepper jack cheese
  • Bacon


  1. Take one buttered slice of bread and lay in pre-heated pan
  2. Place cheddar, then bacon, then pepper jack on top of bread
  3. Top off with other slice of buttered bread
  4. Cook on medium heat until each side is golden brown

Slow cooking is important on a sandwich such as this one.  It’s important to melt the cheese all the way through without burning the bread.  It will take longer before your sandwich is done, but it’s definitely worth the wait.  Have I mentioned I like ketchup with my grilled cheese yet?

Roast beef-muenster-pepper jack grilled cheese

Grilled Cheese

Tonight I figured I might as well continue celebrating National Grilled Cheese month.  I had some thinly sliced roast beef in the fridge that needed eating and plenty of pepper jack left.  Sounds to me like the start of a great grilled cheese.

I grabbed some of the same high fiber 12 grain bread from before.  This time I grabbed my bottle of French’s Spicy Brown Mustard.  If you haven’t tried mustard on a grilled cheese yet, there’s no time like the present.  It adds some amazing flavor.  After the mustard came a layer of muenster, followed by the roast beef, and then pepper jack.  Since it’s hard to butter one side of the bread and add mustard on the other, I went ahead and applied the French’s on top of the cheese.

Grilled cheeseGrilled Cheese

The sandwich turned out amazingly awesome.  I know I was going to have someone else score for me, but that’s always an afterthought while swallowing the last bite.

Taste: 9 (Yes, it was better than the Pepper jack-pepperoni-parmesan grilled cheese)
Originality: 3
Plating: 2

Tim C. Lofton informed me I was a little too harsh on plating so I upped my score by one.  The mustard really highlighted the cheese and roast beef flavors in the sandwich which earned me another point as well.  All in all, another successful sandwich.

Grilled CheeseGrilled Cheese

If you’re having trouble coming up with grilled cheese creations to try, I’d like to suggest you visit http://grilledcheeseacademy.com/.

Pepper jack-pepperoni-parmesan grilled cheese

After my last post, April: National Grilled Cheese Month, I had to make a grilled cheese tonight.  I took stock of what I had and decided to go with pepper jack cheese.  That reminded me of the best pizza place in the Quad Cities, Harris Pizza, where my favorite pizza is pepper jack with either sausage or pepperoni.  To top it all off, I grabbed the parmesan to round out the pizza theme.

I grabbed some high fiber 12 grain bread, laid down a layer of cheese, applied a few pepperonis and then shook on some parmesan.  I also decided to put a nice parm-crust on top and bottom, and it turned out pretty well.

The best way to convey the taste of this sandwich would be through Iron Chef style scoring.  Ten points for flavor, five points for originality, and another five points for plating and presentation.  Here is my scorecard:

Taste:  8
Originality:  3
Plating:  1

The taste was pretty darn good.  And while some people may have never thought to put pepperoni on a grilled cheese sandwich, it’s not that crazy.  I also gave myself one point for plating due to that lovely “GC” in ketchup for Grilled Cheese Month.  Was I fair in my scoring?  Anyone have something to best me?  I’d totally be up for an Iron Chef showdown.

April: National Grilled Cheese Month

April 12, 2011 – A day that will live in infamy.  The day I was too busy traveling to a work conference and missed National Grilled Cheese Day.

Some of you might think I sound melodramatic or even a little ridiculous.  I’m going to have to assume you think the same thing about vets on Veteran’s Day, mothers on Mothers Day, or secretaries on Administrative Professionals Day.  Obviously you don’t care about what really matters.

So back to the fact it’s April and National Grilled Cheese Month.  A lot has happened since the first man ever took some bread and cheese, then grilled it.  I wish we knew who this first man was so we could honor him with a medal.  Or was it a woman?  Now that I think about it, probably was a woman.  Mothers are so great about fixing amazing food for their children.

I’m sure you’re familiar with the standard white bread and American cheese sandwich.  It’s basic and classic, but I’d like to challenge you to try something different this month.  Live a little and see what you can create.  There are a few basic elements to a grilled cheese sandwich we should go over first.

1. Bread

Bread is the first of two main ingredients.  Plain, standard white bread is ok, but there are many other choices out there.  This also plays a factor in cooking time.  I prefer larger slices of bread which always results in a larger sandwich.  Nothing wrong with that.  You might also check out some high fiber, whole grain, whole wheat, rye, artisan, etc.

2. Cheese

Just as with plain white bread, there is the standard processed American cheese.  Processed cheese melts well and comes in handy pre-made slices, but what about cheddar, provalone, muenster, mozzarella, monterey jack, havarti, bleu, brick, asiago, parmesan, gouda, and anything else you can find?  I enjoy mixing and combining cheeses.  Feel free to experiment with two or three.  Some even cook shredded cheese into the outside of the bread for a nice crust.

3. Extras

Here’s where you can get fancy by adding sauces, vegetables, fruits, and meats.  Some add tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, apples, salami, ham, pickles, mustards – anything that tastes good.  You might find yourself treading into the territory of other pre-defined sandwiches and that’s ok because we all know from Geometry class that a square is really a special type of rectangle.

4. Cooking

Here’s the part where you finalize your creation by melting that cheese.  I used to use an electric skillet.  I enjoyed this because I knew exactly what the temperature was.  I figured out how long and at what temperature I needed to cook each grilled cheese based on how dense the bread was and what kind of cheese I was cooking.  Denser breads require more heat to melt the cheese.  Denser cheeses take longer to heat.  What I’m really trying to say is if your heat is too high, you’ll burn the bread and not melt the cheese, and while some like food burned, this would not be the preferred outcome.

If you use an electric stove or a gas stove, you should also experiment to see what works best.  Gas stoves have immediate heat while electric stoves take time to get hot.  An easy mistake to make is to turn on an electric stove too high, and then once side 1 is cooked, side 2 is burned as the heat continues to rise.  An easy way to avoid this mistake is to let your pan pre-heat, just like you’d do for something cooked in the oven, so your heat is more stable before making your sandwich.  And last but not least, don’t forget the butter.  Generously apply it to the outer sides of your bread to help protect it from burning.  One last tip is to match your bread slices the same way you took them out of the bag.  This will help to ensure a better cheese seal and you shouldn’t lose much oozing out into the pan.

So that’s all I have for now.  How do you cook your grilled cheese?  What do you put in it?  What bread do you use?  Do you add any extras?  Please share.  It’s National Grilled Cheese month and no one likes a humbug.